Understanding Credit Card Processing Fees and Surcharges: A Simple Guide

November 13, 2024

If you're running a business, you've likely encountered the term credit card service charge and experienced the sting of these fees eating into your profits. 

Accepting credit cards is almost a necessity for businesses today, but it's not without cost. The fees associated with processing credit card payments can add up, and understanding them is critical to managing your business expenses more effectively.

In this blog, we'll break down everything you need to know about credit card processing fees and surcharges. From how these fees are structured to the strategies you can use to reduce costs, we'll cover it all. Let's dive into the details of how credit card processing fees work and how you can keep them from cutting too deeply into your profits.

Introduction to Credit Card Processing Fees

Credit card processing fees are the costs businesses incur when processing credit and debit card transactions. These fees are typically charged as a percentage of each transaction, along with a small fixed fee. While the charges may seem small at first glance, they can quickly add up—especially for businesses with high transaction volumes.

How These Fees Impact Merchants and Consumers

Credit card service charges are an unavoidable cost of doing business. Every time a customer pays with a credit card, part of that transaction goes toward covering the processing fees, leaving the company with a smaller profit. Some companies opt to pass these fees on to their customers through surcharges or by raising prices, while others absorb the cost themselves.

Consumers, meanwhile, generally don't notice these fees directly. However, they may encounter slightly higher prices in businesses that pass the charges along. Either way, credit card processing fees affect both businesses and customers.

But what exactly are these fees? Let's examine the key components of credit card processing costs.

Key Components of Credit Card Processing Fees

The total credit card service charge is composed of several different fees that are split between various entities, including the card-issuing bank, the card network (such as Visa or Mastercard), and the payment processor. These fees can vary depending on the type of transaction, the card used, and other factors.

Interchange Fees: Role and Variability

Interchange fees are set by the card networks and paid to the bank that issued the customer's credit card. These fees usually make up the largest portion of the overall processing cost and vary depending on the type of card and transaction. For instance, transactions made with premium rewards cards tend to carry higher interchange fees than those made with standard debit cards.

Assessment Fees: Set by Card Networks

Assessment fees are small charges that card networks (like Visa, Mastercard, or American Express) collect on each transaction. While these fees are much smaller than interchange fees—usually just a fraction of a percent of the transaction amount—they still contribute to the total credit card service charge.

Payment Processor Fees: Additional Charges and Structures

Payment processors tack on their own fees on top of interchange and assessment fees. These cover the cost of facilitating the transaction between the customer's and merchant's banks. The structure and amount of payment processor fees can vary depending on the pricing model used.

Ready to reduce your credit card processing fees? Contact us today to explore your options and negotiate better rates.

Now that we've broken down the components of credit card processing fees let's explore the different pricing models payment processors use.

Credit Card Processing Pricing Models

Payment processors typically offer several different pricing models for credit card transactions. Understanding the differences between these models can help you choose the one that best suits your business needs and transaction volume.

Flat-Rate Pricing: Simplicity and Cost Implications

Flat-rate pricing is the simplest model—your business pays the same fee for every transaction, regardless of the card type or how the transaction is processed. For example, a processor might charge 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction, whether it's a debit card or a high-end rewards card. While this model is easy to understand and predictable, it can sometimes result in higher costs for businesses that handle a lot of low-risk transactions, such as in-person debit payments.

Tiered Pricing: Categorization Based on Transaction Risk

Tiered pricing splits transactions into different tiers—qualified, mid-qualified, and non-qualified—based on factors like the type of card used and how the transaction was processed. 

Qualified transactions, which are typically lower-risk (like in-person payments with a primary debit card), have the lowest fees. Non-qualified transactions, such as online payments or those made with premium cards, have the highest fees. While more complex, this model may offer lower rates for businesses with a lot of low-risk transactions.

Interchange-Plus Pricing: Transparency and Detailed Breakdown

Interchange-plus pricing is often considered the most transparent option. With this structure, you pay the actual interchange fee plus a fixed markup from the processor. 

For instance, if the interchange fee for a transaction is 1.8% and your processor charges a 0.3% markup, your total credit card service charge would be 2.1%. This model allows businesses to see exactly where their fees are going and can be more cost-effective for higher transaction volumes.

Membership-Based Pricing: Benefits for High-Volume Transactions

Membership-based pricing works differently by charging a flat monthly fee to the payment processor, along with interchange fees for each transaction. This model can be ideal for businesses with high transaction volumes, as it provides predictable costs and eliminates percentage markups.

Also read- Successful Techniques for Debt Collection from Business Customers.

Now that we've explored how pricing models work let's examine surcharges and how they factor into credit card service charges.

Understanding Credit Card Surcharges

Surcharges are additional fees that businesses may choose to add to credit card transactions to offset processing costs. While not all businesses implement surcharges, those that do need to understand how they work and the legal considerations involved.

Definition and Purpose of Surcharges

A surcharge is a fee added to a customer's bill when they pay with a credit card. The goal is to help businesses recoup the costs of credit card service charges. For example, a company might add a 3% surcharge to credit card payments to cover the processing fees they incur.

Legal Status Across States

Not all states permit surcharges. For instance, states like California, Florida, and New York have laws that restrict or outright ban credit card surcharges. If you're thinking about implementing surcharges, be sure to check your state's laws to ensure compliance.

Surcharges vs. Convenience Fees

It's also essential to distinguish surcharges from convenience fees. While surcharges cover credit card processing costs, convenience fees are charged when customers use an alternative payment method, such as paying online instead of in person. Convenience fees often apply in industries like utilities or education and are subject to different regulations than surcharges.

With a better understanding of surcharges, let's delve into the rules and regulations that govern them.

Regulations and Legalities of Credit Card Surcharges

When implementing surcharges, businesses must follow specific rules set by major credit card networks, along with federal and state laws.

Surcharging Rules Set by Visa and Mastercard

Visa and Mastercard have strict guidelines regarding surcharges. For example, merchants must inform customers about surcharges before completing a transaction, and the surcharge cannot exceed the credit card service charge. Additionally, businesses must display clear signage at the point of sale or on their website to notify customers of the surcharge.

Restrictions on Debit Card Surcharges

Surcharges cannot be applied to debit card transactions, even if the debit card is processed as a credit card. Visa and Mastercard have set this key rule.

Overview of State-Specific Surcharge Laws

As mentioned earlier, several states have laws that restrict or prohibit surcharges. Suppose you operate in a state with such laws. In that case, you may need to explore alternative ways to offset your processing costs, such as offering cash discounts or negotiating lower rates with your payment processor.

Also read- Successful Techniques for Debt Collection from Business Customers.

Let's now move on to strategies for reducing the impact of credit card processing fees on your business.

Strategies to Offset Credit Card Processing Fees

While credit card processing fees are unavoidable, there are strategies you can use to reduce their impact on your bottom line.

Implementing Surcharges Legally

If surcharges are allowed in your state, they can help pass the cost of processing fees to your customers. Just ensure that you follow the rules around disclosure and signage and stay within the allowable limits for surcharge amounts.

Offering Discounts for Cash Payments

Offering discounts to customers who pay with cash is an alternative to surcharges. This can encourage customers to choose a payment method that doesn't come with processing fees, saving your business money. Cash discounts are legal in all 50 states and can be an effective way to reduce credit card service charges.

Negotiating with Processors for Better Rates

Feel free to negotiate with your payment processor. Suppose your business processes a high volume of transactions. In that case, you can secure a lower rate or a more favorable pricing model. Even small reductions in fees can lead to significant savings over time.

Managing fees is a crucial step to understand credit card processing fees. Let’s understand.

Practical Tips for Managing Fees

Managing credit card processing fees effectively requires informed decisions and proactive planning. Here are a few tips to help you keep costs in check.

Choosing a Suitable Pricing Model for Your Business

Take the time to evaluate which pricing model best fits your business. For example, if you handle a high transaction volume, interchange-plus or membership-based pricing could lead to better savings than flat-rate pricing.

Optimizing Transaction Methods to Minimize Costs

Encourage in-person transactions whenever possible, as they usually carry lower fees than online or keyed-in payments. Additionally, ensure that your payment terminal is equipped with the latest security features to avoid higher costs associated with increased fraud risk.

Frequently Reviewing Payment Processor Options

Your business needs can change over time, and so should your payment processor setup. Make it a habit to regularly review your processor's fees and services to ensure you're getting the best deal. If your transaction volume has increased, you might even find better rates elsewhere.

Let’s go over what we have discussed in the next section.

Conclusion

Understanding credit card service charges and surcharges is essential for managing your business expenses effectively. By knowing the components of processing fees, choosing the right pricing model, and exploring strategies to reduce costs, you can minimize the impact of these fees on your bottom line.

Ultimately, staying informed and proactive about managing credit card service charges will help you maintain healthy profit margins while still offering customers the convenience of paying with credit cards.

Looking to lower your credit card processing fees? Start by reviewing your current processor's rates and exploring strategies to reduce your credit card service charge today! You can also contact South District Group for more about credit card management.

Table of content

Recent Blogs