Understanding Credit Card Processing Fees and Surcharges: A Simple Guide

Tamar Redden
November 13, 2024

Have you ever wondered why, every time a customer uses a credit card to make a purchase, your business loses a chunk of its revenue? Understanding credit card processing fees is crucial to maintaining healthy profit margins, whether you're a small business owner or a large enterprise. 

Since these hidden expenses may mount up quickly, many businesses are confused about reducing them without losing customers.

In this guide, we'll break down credit card service charges and surcharges in simple terms. You'll discover why they exist, how they affect your profitability, and how to manage or minimize them effectively. Ultimately, you can make better decisions that improve customer satisfaction and profitability. 

What Are Credit Card Processing Fees?

Credit card processing fees are incurred when your business accepts credit card payments. Usually, banks, payment processors, and card issuers split these costs. Even while the fees might not seem like much, they can build up over time to reach a substantial amount.

These fees aim mainly to offset the expenses of upholding a safe and effective payment system. Processing payments involves complex fraud detection, data encryption, and transaction verification systems. These back-end processes guarantee that your business is paid promptly and safely. 

Types of Credit Card Processing Fees

You'll generally encounter a few different types of fees when dealing with credit card transactions:

  • Transaction Fees: Transaction fees are charged for each transaction and are frequently determined by your sales volume.
  • Monthly Fees: Regardless of the volume of transactions you handle, some providers charge a fixed monthly price for using their services.
  • Per-Transaction Fees: These consist of a set charge in addition to a percentage of the entire transaction amount.

While these fees may seem inevitable, understanding each type can help you negotiate better rates or adjust your pricing strategy to account for them.

Next, let's break down the individual components of credit card service charges. 

Breaking Down the Components of Credit Card Service Charges

To better understand credit card processing fees, let's explore the different components that make up these charges. The more you know, the more equipped you will be in managing expenses.

This chart highlights the differences in fees for each card type, with American Express generally having higher interchange fees.

  1. Interchange Fees

These are the fees that your payment processor pays to the card-issuing bank. The biggest portion of credit card service fees are usually interchange fees, which might vary depending on the card used (such as business or rewards cards) and the transaction's risk level.  In the United States, interchange fees typically fall between 1.5% and 2.5% for each transaction.

  1. Assessment Fees

These are fees collected by card networks like Visa, MasterCard, or American Express. Although they usually have lower rates than interchange fees, they can still increase over time. These fees help cover the cost of managing the card network and ensuring that transactions are processed correctly. 

  1. Payment Gateway Fees

A payment gateway is a service that facilitates the communication between your website and the payment processor. The gateway may charge a small fee for every transaction, usually a few cents per transaction. Depending on the gateway you select, this cost may change.

  1. Markups by Payment Processors

Lastly, your payment processor may add a markup to the interchange and assessment fees. These markups may differ depending on the service provider and their pricing structure. While some processors use a "tiered" approach based on transaction volume, others might offer "flat-rate pricing" with a fixed percentage fee.

While these components can make credit card processing costs seem complex, understanding each part can help you identify areas for cost-saving.

For example, collaborating with a service partner like South East Client Services (SECS), which offers customized portfolio management and acquisition services, can assist you in determining more effective approaches to managing receivablesincluding optimizing payment strategies and minimizing unnecessary fees.

With a better understanding of the components, let's examine how surcharges work and what you need to know before implementing them. 

What Are Surcharges and How Do They Work?

A credit card surcharge is an additional fee added to the total price of a purchase when a customer pays using a credit card. This charge is intended to help offset the expenses of taking credit card payments, especially the processing fees businesses must pay. Although not all businesses add a surcharge, some opt for it to keep their prices competitive without absorbing all the costs.

Many industries, particularly those with thin profit margins like retail and hospitality, frequently impose surcharges. However, there are significant legal considerations businesses must keep in mind when adding surcharges. 

For instance, surcharges are limited to 3% in the United States. Additionally, companies risk legal consequences if they fail to notify customers before the surcharge. 

Example of Surcharge Use:

A business like a restaurant may add a 2.5% surcharge for credit card payments to cover the costs of processing fees. By doing this, the business may avoid boosting menu pricing, which might have a negative impact on sales.

However, it's essential to approach surcharges carefully. Businesses must weigh the benefits of recouping processing fees against the potential drawbacks of alienating customers. So, understanding the different types of service charges and surcharges that companies encounter is important.

Types of Credit Card Service Charges and Surcharges

Knowing how to reduce credit card fees requires an understanding of their structure. Knowing the various pricing structures that payment processors employ to charge businesses helps you select the best one for your requirements. 

  1. Flat Fees vs. Percentage-Based Fees
  • Flat Fee:

 The processor charges a fixed amount per transaction, no matter the payment size.

  • Example: If a processor charges a flat fee of $0.30 per transaction, a $10 and $500 sales incur the same $0.30 fee. This benefits businesses with high-value transactions but can be costly for smaller ones.
  • Percentage-Based Fee: 

The processor takes a percentage of the transaction value instead of a fixed amount.

  • Example: If the fee is 2.9%, a $100 transaction will incur a $2.90 fee, while a $500 transaction will cost $14.50 in processing fees. This model scales with the transaction amount, making it predictable but potentially expensive for high-value sales.
  1. Tiered Pricing

According to the type of card and transaction risk, this method divides transactions into several pricing tiers. Usually, there are three levels:

  • Qualified: 

Standard transactions with basic credit cards—lowest fees.

  • Mid-Qualified: 

Transactions with rewards cards or manually entered transactions—medium fees.

  • Non-Qualified: 

High-risk transactions, business credit cards, or international cards—highest fees.

Example: A corporate rewards card transaction may incur a 3.5% cost, whereas a typical debit card transaction may incur a 1.5% fee. With this model, businesses that take a range of cards may face unexpected expenses. 

  1. Flat-Rate Pricing

Regardless of the card type or transaction size, the same % fee is applied to every transaction. This model is simple and predictable.

Example: If a processor charges 2.75% per transaction, a $100 sale will always result in a $2.75 fee, whether the customer uses a debit or a high-end rewards card.

Although it might not be the most affordable choice for large-scale operations, this price structure is ideal for small enterprises who wish to avoid fluctuating fees. 

  1. Interchange-Plus Pricing

The business pays the interchange fee (set by the card networks) plus a small markup by the processor. This is one of the most transparent models, allowing businesses to see exactly where their money goes.

Example: If Visa's interchange fee is 1.8% + $0.10 per transaction, and the processor adds 0.5% + $0.05, the total fee for a $100 transaction would be $2.35 ($1.80 + $0.10 + $0.50 + $0.05).

Larger businesses benefit from this model because they can negotiate the markup and reduce costs over time.

Each pricing model has advantages and disadvantages depending on your company's size and type. Knowing how these fees are calculated helps you choose the best option for optimizing your payment processing costs.

How Do Credit Card Fees Affect Your Business?

Credit card processing fees can take a noticeable chunk out of your profits, especially for businesses with tight margins. These costs may add up if you work in sectors like retail or hospitality. Businesses typically pay processing fees ranging from 1.5% to 3.5% of each transaction. Here's how these fees can affect your business:

The above line graph shows the cumulative impact of credit card processing fees on a business's profit margin over time.

  • Increased Costs: Even a tiny percentage fee quickly mounts up for a company that handles many transactions. A $100 sale with a 2.5% fee results in a $2.50 charge. If you make hundreds or thousands of transactions per day, that adds up.
  • Impact on Profit Margins: These fees have the potential to lower profitability in low-margin industries like e-commerce or restaurants significantly. Your revenue may decline with a slight change in fees.
  • Customer Behavior: Customers may feel uncomfortable paying more when businesses impose surcharges to offset costs. Some might decide to pay with cash, skip the surcharge entirely, or choose a competitor that doesn't charge additional fees.
  • Limitations on Payment Methods: Your company may suffer if you refuse to take credit cards or restrict the ways that customers can pay, particularly in today's increasingly cashless society. Customers expect flexibility in how they pay. 

Pro Tip: To better limit fees, consider negotiating cheaper rates with your payment processor or looking into interchange-plus pricing. Simplifying payment processes and reducing chargebacks are further ways to cut costs.

Understanding how to manage these fees effectively is key to maintaining healthy margins. Now, let's explore practical strategies to lower processing costs and boost revenue. 

Strategies to Minimize Credit Card Processing Fees

While avoiding all processing fees is impossible, there are ways to reduce them and mitigate their impact. Here are some proven strategies:

  1. Negotiate with Processors: Many processors are open to negotiation, mainly if you handle many transactions. Don't hesitate to ask for a better rate or discount.
  2. Choose a Low-Cost Payment Gateway: Seek out a payment gateway that offers flat-rate pricing or reduced fees so businesses can make informed decisions by being aware of all costs upfront.
  3. Encourage Other Payment Methods: Since bank transfers and debit cards are frequently cheaper than credit cards, encourage customers to use these alternate payment methods.
  4. Optimize Transaction Methods: Reducing chargebacks, fraud, and failed transactions can help lower processing fees over time. Using validated payment processors and implementing more robust security measures can help achieve this. 

You may lower your fees and increase profitability by carefully managing your payments. Understanding the regulations and legislation related to credit card service fees is essential to strengthen your payment plan. Let's examine what you need to know to maintain compliance and avoid costly mistakes. 

Understanding Legalities and Regulations Around Credit Card Service Charges

To stay out of trouble and maintain customers' trust, managing the legal aspects of credit card service fees is crucial. Businesses are subject to several federal and state rules that control how they charge and disclose fees. Here's what you need to know:

  1. The CARD Act: The Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure (CARD) Act requires businesses to disclose surcharges or fees before completing the transaction. This guarantees transparency and safeguards customers.
  2. State-Specific Regulations: Surcharge laws may vary from one state to another. Some might limit fees completely, while others would restrict the amount you can add to a credit card transaction. Always check your state's laws to ensure compliance. 
  3. Clear Disclosure: It's crucial to disclose surcharges upfront. Customers must know exactly what they're being charged at the point of sale, online checkout, or on the receipt. Failure to do so could result in legal issues and customer dissatisfaction.
  4. Potential Penalties: Violating these guidelines may result in penalties, legal action, and damage to your company's reputation. You can protect yourself by keeping up with rules and ensuring that your fee structures adhere to them.

Pro Tip: If you're unsure about the legalities or need help staying compliant, South East Client Services (SECS) can guide you through the regulatory maze and help optimize your payment processes.

You may prevent expensive errors and guarantee a satisfying customer experience by being aware of these guidelines and upholding transparency.

After discussing these legal issues, let's wrap up with some key takeaways to help you manage credit card fees effectively. 

Conclusion

Credit card service charges are unavoidable in business, but you can minimize their impact by understanding the components and pricing models. From negotiating better rates to staying compliant with legal regulations, managing these fees requires strategic planning and careful attention. You may increase your profitability and cut down on unnecessary costs by putting the appropriate strategies into practice.

South East Client Services (SECS) can be a valuable partner when navigating the complexities of credit card processing. By streamlining payment processing, SECS assists companies in maintaining regulatory compliance and cutting expenses for sustained profitability. With their expert guidance, you may minimize processing fees and focus on growing your business.

Are you ready to take charge of your payment processing and cut down on those unwanted fees? Reach out to SECS today and start optimizing your payment strategy!

Table of content

Recent Blogs